Buyer’s Guide to Vintages September 7th Release

Harvest & Storm Clouds in Ontario

By John Szabo MS, with notes from Sara d’Amato, David Lawrason and Michael Godel

The week’s report features the September 7 Vintages Release and the LCBO’s annual harvest-time focus on Ontario. The Vintages circular offers flashy spreads and ample coverage of Ontario wineries, with special emphasis on advancements in sustainability, the rise of hands-off winemaking, and the ongoing search for ever-finer distinctions across the province. It’s worth a read to brush up on some of the important developments that have taken place within the Ontario wine industry, ones which have and will continue to elevate wines on the world stage. I also highlight a few below.

But as local vintners head into the busiest and most exciting time of the year, storm clouds are gathering, at least metaphorical ones. VQA Ontario wines currently represent a pitiful 5% of LCBO wine sales, down from previous years. Read on for Finance Minister Peter Bethlenfalvy’s stern directives to the LCBO to right the ship, and also for the WineAlign Crü’s top Ontario picks from the release, including a rare marsanne with equally rare quadruple alignment, should you want to help notch that market share up.

And also alarmingly, the Grape Growers of Ontario, the independent organization that represents more than 500 grape growers and 18,000 acres of vineyards across the province, are predicting a massive surplus of grapes this vintage, the worst oversupply since 2009 according to CEO Debbie Zimmerman. And this amidst the tragic harvest in the Okanagan Valley, where virtually no fruit will be picked this year thanks to January’s brutal cold snap, and many wineries have been scrambling to buy (the also massive oversupply) of grapes from Washington State. B.C. growers, take note: There are grapes for sale in Ontario. And speaking of foreign wines, the Crü also shares top picks from September 7, including a cracking Châteauneuf-du-Pape and a superb and an affordable red Bordeaux from the legendary 2010 vintage that’s drinking beautifully now.

What’s Going on In Ontario

“Taking environmental stewardship seriously is at the core of what we do for a living,” says Gabriel Demarco, winemaker at Cave Spring Vineyard. Earlier this summer Demarco called me up to share the learnings from cover crop trials he’s been running, clearly bubbling with excitement by the results. Ironically, as I was pulling weeds in my own vineyard in Prince Edward County and dripping with sweat while on the phone, Demarco enthused about the success he’s had weaponizing alfalfa, white clover and red clover in the battle against weeds.

Aggressive, tall weeds that grow up into the vine canopy are problematic. They reduce air flow and thus increase disease pressure, as moisture tends to hang around longer on leaves and grapes, creating perfect conditions for mildews to flourish. This is one of the principal challenges when growing grapes in a humid climate like southern Ontario’s.

Mechanical weeding by tractor is expensive and time consuming (and boring) and burns a lot of diesel, while clearing by hand is even more so (and good luck finding a crew that wants to hand hoe your vineyard). It’s little wonder many growers rely on herbicides to kill weeds under row — it’s much faster and cheaper, even if terrible for microbial life in soils, a factor whose critical importance is becoming ever-more obvious to farmers. Look for the telltale, perfectly linear strip of brown, lifeless soil under rows of vines when next driving through wine country. That’s herbicide in action.

But, according to Demarco, low-creeping clovers don’t grow high enough to suffocate the vines, and, importantly, they are “rapid-growing and outcompete weeds,” reducing or eliminating the need for herbicides. Clover also attracts beneficial insects, like bees, another obvious benefit. Stratus Vineyards has run similar trials with big success; winemaker Dean Stoyka is equally buoyant about the potential to eliminate herbicides altogether with both permanent inter-row and under-row cover crops based on clovers. Wide implementation of under-row cover crops would massively reduce the use of herbicides in Ontario.

Cave Spring is also on the cutting edge of ultra-violet weed-control technology. They have partnered with Haggerty AgRobotics and AgricUltra to design a Canadian-patented system that uses energy-efficient LED U.V. light to kill weeds. It’s another potential game-changer, especially adding electric tractors into the mix, already in use in vineyards.

Similarly, Vineland Estate is trialling a combination of ultraviolet light, ozone and hydrogen peroxide to attack mildews and fungus. “The results,” says Brian Schmidt, “are unbelievably promising.” Fungal diseases are typically controlled by toxic chemical sprays in conventionally farmed vineyards, but this new Canadian technology could significantly reduce the need for fungicides, not to mention save farmers thousands of dollars per year spent on the chemical products.

It’s heartening to see Ontario take a leading role in developing such innovative techniques that could change viticulture worldwide for the better.

Doing Less But Finding More

Along with advancing sustainability, Ontario winemakers are also increasingly obsessed with doing less in the winery in order to uncover more of the nuanced differences between vineyard parcels and sub-regions. “If there’s one thing Burgundy has taught me, it’s the importance of regional nuance,” says Thomas Bachelder, who has obsessed with terroir more than perhaps anyone in Ontario. “We’ve been mapping out the entire Niagara Peninsula from Vinemount to Niagara River to identify key factors in between,” he says, with a huge range of single vineyards on offer to prove the point. Tasting through them is always one of the highlights of the WineAlign tasting calendar year (if exhausting).

But Bachelder is hardly alone. “Perhaps the most exciting thing about making wine in Niagara,” says vintner Taylor Emerson of Black Bank Hill, “is the evolving and ongoing process of discovery; exploring the terroir and uncovering what makes us special and unique.” And Emerson’s refrain is heard throughout Ontario.

It now seems clear to Ontario winemakers, as elsewhere around the world, that the key to unlocking, the special and unique characteristics of a given vineyard is to do as little as possible to the incoming grapes, rather than to attempt to impose a style on a wine through a series of aggressive interventions in the winery. With the huge arsenal of techniques and approved winemaking additives available to vintners, it’s relatively easy to craft a wine to boardroom or focus-group specs. But such wines obviously crush the importance of place, the one thing that matters most to fine wine lovers.

“There’s an ethos to being an organic producer,” says Harald Thiel of Hidden Bench, a long time organic-biodynamic producer on the Niagara Escarpment. “Using indigenous yeasts, hand-picking, low intervention, all allows Beamsville Bench’s terroir to speak for itself.”

Len Pennachetti of Cave Spring adds another dimension of revelation through low-fi techniques. “I love crafting wine with low intervention, to allow for the vintage variation in each wine to speak in the glass,” he says, reflecting on the significant year-to-year differences experienced in Ontario. For Pennachetti, this is something to be celebrated, not ironed-out.

These are all very positive developments for the Ontario wine industry, a story to follow along as it unfolds.

Stern Directives from the Finance Minister to the LCBO

Recognizing the alarmingly poor performance of 100% Ontario-grown wines a at the LCBO, representing a paltry 5% of the sales mix, Ontario Finance minister Peter Bethlenfalvy sent a pointed letter to LCBO chair Carmine Nigro recently outlining ways to potentially increase market share for Ontario wines.

“With marketplace expansion around the corner and increased consumer demand for local Ontario products and those of other small producers, I am now directing the LCBO…to create more opportunities to promote these products in LCBO’s retail and wholesale operations,” Bethlenfalvy’s letter said. The LCBO, which reports to the Ministry of Finance, would seem obliged to implement the suggestions.

“In support of this direction, and while being mindful of Ontario’s trade obligations, I would like the LCBO to undertake the activities below during the lead up to and post launch of Phase 1 of retail expansion this summer. LCBO shall consult with government and stakeholders to inform these activities,” he wrote, and included several areas of improvement he would like to see take place.

Here’s what Bethlenfalvy suggests:

• Establish an internal/external champion who will lead the LCBO’s efforts to respond to consumer demands for local Ontario products.
• Establish a collaborative forum with local Ontario industries to understand the needs of the industry.
• Provide prominent merchandising space, signage, and promotional opportunities for small and local Ontario producers that reflect consumer trends and demands.
• Update LCBO public reporting to separate out and highlight the successes of small alcohol producers.
• Develop a plan to measure progress and targets in supporting these initiatives.
• Develop training supports for retail employees to highlight small and local Ontario alcohol producers, for which there is increased consumer demand and interest.
• Leverage LCBO Food and Drink and digital advertising assets to be an active partner for small and local Ontario alcohol producers.
• Implement supply chain and inventory strategies to better assist small and local Ontario alcohol producers in response to increased consumer demand for these products.

It remains to be seen which of these points will be addressed, and how fast. Stay tuned.

In the meantime, celebrate harvest time with a glass or two of VQA Ontario wine. Below are our suggestions.

Buyer’s Guide September 7: Ontario White

Kew Vineyards Marsanne 2020, Ontario, Canada
$19.95, Arterra Wines Canada
John Szabo – One of the rare (only?) marsannes in Ontario, and a small handful in Canada, KEW’s 2020 has shifted into a mature, bottle-aged expression from these experimental 1975 plantings, smoky, like old Hunter Valley Semillon – it’s idiosyncratic- but there’s a lot of appeal. A wine that will captivate a handful of people no doubt. Intrepid drinkers take note.
Sara d’Amato – Marsanne isn’t found much around these parts, a grape whose origins are in France’s northern Rhône Valley where it is often blended with roussanne. A pleasant surprise, this Beamsville Bench-grown expression is perfectly ripe, distinctive but not showy, and a notable value.
David Lawrason – Since when is a rare Rhone variety supposed to work so well in Niagara. It is a classic marsanne with, perfumed aromas of orange marmalade, yellow flowers, and spice. It is quite full bodied yet braced by good acidity, warmth and a lovely sense of fennel/licorice on the finish.
Michael Godel – If you knew how little marsanne there is planted in Ontario then you’d know what a unicorn this truly is. Succulent and conversely grippy, which translates as phenolic to underscore exactly what the grape should be. The definition of a discovery wine.

Tawse Limestone Ridge North Riesling 2021, Ontario, Canada
$21.95, Tawse
David Lawrason – Very impressive riesling with intense aromas of petrol, crushed pineapple, lemonade and a touch of evergreen. It carries great intensity on the palate with searing acidity, offset by some sweetness. The length is excellent. Relentless flavour and quench.

Hidden Bench Estate Organic Riesling 2020, Ontario, Canada
$24.95, Mark Anthony Group
Sara d’Amato – A gold medal winner at the National Wine Awards for good reason, this Beamsville Bench cuvée shows significant consistency vintage-to-vintage. Potently perfumed and sapid with palpable tension and impressive richness. We should be thankful it is underpriced.

Le Clos Jordanne Jordan Village Chardonnay 2021, Ontario, Canada
$30.00, Arterra Wines Canada
John Szabo – This could well be the finest of recent LCJ Village chardonnay releases with its appealing creamy citrus, orange and lemon brulée flavours, and creamy, soft and fluffy palate with excellent length.

Black Bank Hill Chardonnay 2020, Ontario, Canada
$34.95, Black Bank Hill
David Lawrason – From a new winery that finished Top Ten in Ontario in the 2024 National Wine Awards, this is a quite opulent Niagara chardonnay from a ripe vintage. Expect rich peachy fruit and considerable barrel works creating crème brûlée, cashew and light toast. More oaked than what is currently in fashion, but it carries well.
Michael Godel – Hard to not appreciate the ripeness in this 2020 chardonnay from one of Niagara’s newer wineries on an expedient upward trajectory into high level wines. This has aged in the most ideal way imaginable and for my money drinks finer than the 2021, at least at this stage.

Buyer’s Guide September 7: Ontario Red

Cave Spring Estate Grown Cabernet Franc 2022, Ontario, Canada
$20.95, CAVE SPRING CELLARS
Sara d’Amato – Untamed and expressive, this characterful cabernet franc may be a little edgy, but it is so wildly compelling that I’m prepared to forgive its little eccentricities. Tannins are soft-chalky on the palate that offers an abundance of black and red fruit, bramble, anise and bay leaf, with angular acidity and mouthwatering freshness.
Michael Godel – Speaks to the Cave Spring Vineyard and the important farming adjustments made over these last few years by Gabe Demarco and team. The fruit is singing because their host vines are well loved. It’s as simple as that.

Henry Of Pelham School House Cabernet/Merlot 2020, Ontario, Canada
$27.95, HENRY OF PELHAM FAMILY EST. WINERY
John Szabo – A big, ripe, vaguely Spanish style Niagara red from the unusually warm 2020 vintage, inflected with American oak I would guess given the sandalwood, melted butter and balsam flavours typically encountered in, say, traditional-style Rioja reds. This would be a tough one to guess in a blind tasting, but I have to say, I like the stylishness of the wine, ready to enjoy or hold late into the decade.
Sara d’Amato – A silver medal winner at this year’s National Wine Awards of Canada, Henry of Pelham’s estate-grown School House blend is generous and structured wine with welcome hints of salinity, bitterness, and underlying acidity that combine to provide freshness and balance. A fine vintage that should age gracefully over the mid-term.

Buyer’s Guide September 7: White

Huber Vision Grüner Veltliner 2022, Niederösterreich, Austria
$16.95, Rogers & Company
Sara d’Amato – There is nothing terribly complex about this grüner, but it offers an abundance of charm, freshness, and a stylishly reductive character making it a delight to sip over the short term. An accessibly priced entry level find from Markus Huber with notable varietal typicity and a crowd-pleasing nature.

Château De Chasseloir Muscadet De Sèvre Et Maine 2020, Loire, France
$21.95, Family Wine Merchants
Sara d’Amato – Get hooked on aging Muscadet with this well-priced find just nearing its prime. Aged on its lees, melon b., as the grape is now known, has the potential to develop to great heights in bottle. Château de Chasseloir owns some of the oldest grapes in the region with vineyards over 50 years of age and a five hectares plot of vines that is over 100 years old. This classic entry level cuvée was aged on its lees for over 6 months and features a texture that is both lofty and ethereal with light toastiness and trailing notes of pear and honeysuckle.
Michael Godel – Scintillant stuff, prominent and built on extreme focus for grape and place. Not to be missed. Save a bottle for three or four years and get ready for new magic to happen.

Gradis’ciutta Ribolla Gialla 2021, Friuli-Venezia Giulia, Italy
$23.95, LES 2 RAISINS
John Szabo – I’m a fan of the yellow fruit flavours and firm acids of Ribolla Gialla, and Robert Princic of Gradis’ciutta does a superb job with it from his organically-farmed vineyards on Collio’s signature ‘ponca’ (marly-sandstone-limestone) soils. The ‘21is is gently fragrant and delicate, turning more savoury and chewy on the palate with firm structure. I also like the saline-savoury side behind it all.
Sara d’Amato – Rarely found outside of northeastern Italy and in Slovenia, ribollo gialla is well worth getting to know with its lively acids, flavours of just-ripe peach, and apple blossom. This is a particularly bright and salty incarnation with notable mineral and lemongrass. Features plenty of textural intrigue and memorable length.

Buyer’s Guide September 7: Red

Château Saint Roch Chimères Grenache/Carignan/Syrah 2021, Midi, France
$19.95, Glencairn Wine Merchants
John Szabo – Fantastic Roussillon red here from the Lafage family, classically styled in the blue fruit camp, with scorched earth and wild herbs mingling on a large frame, declared at 15% alcohol, though surprisingly well balanced. Bold, satisfying, attractively priced.

Château Laurou Les Complices 2020, Southwest, France
$19.95, Nicholas Pearce Wines Inc.
Sara d’Amato – The hilly, gravelly soils just to the north of Toulouse are perfectly suited to the fragrant negrette variety in the appellation of Fronton that requires the inclusion of a significant portion of the grape in its blends. Aromas of violet are particularly apparent here as well as purple plum and hints of licorice. Soft tannins and demure acids make for a highly gulpable wine with a pleasantly uncomplicated nature.

Château Peyros Tannat/Cabernet 2020, Southwest, France
$17.95, Profile Wine Group (Vin Vino)
David Lawrason – This leading Madiran producer has cleverly blended cabernet franc to tame the tannic edge of tannat – the mainstay red grape of this appellation. This is solid yet almost elegant intense with blackcurrant, deep violet/black rose, herbaceous note oak and some. Fairly dense yet sleek.

Best’s Bin No. 1 Great Western Shiraz 2021, Victoria, Australia
$19.95, Family Wine Merchants
David Lawrason – Higher altitude Great Western, in the Grampian Range northwest of Melbourne, delivers a style of shiraz with more acidity, menthol and pepper – reflecting northern Rhone. There is subtle meatiness as well. Medium-full bodied, firm and warm with cranberry-cherry fruit hitting excellent length.

Grupo Yllera Pepe Yllera 2020, Ribera Del Duero, Spain
$20.95, John Hanna & Sons
John Szabo – A co-production of the Yllera family and Jean-Claude Berrouet (Pétrus, Dominus), this is ripe and darkly fruity, supple and plush tempranillo, with plenty of underlying savouriness and spicy-integrated oak flavours. Lots of wine here for $22, drinking now, or hold to 2027 or 2028.

Château De Belcier 2010, Bordeaux, France
$24.95, BanQPay International
John Szabo – A fine of example of the serious value coming out of Bordeaux amidst all the hype and press around a handful of truly expensive wines, this is fully mature Bordeaux from a fantastic vintage. It delivers far more depth and certainly complexity than one could reasonably hope for in the price category these days.

Palacio Glorioso Reserva 2018, Spain
$23.95, Hanna Neal Wine Merchants (John Hanna & Sons)
David Lawrason – An unusually energized, captivating Rioja! Lots of lift on the nose with classic red fruits, herbals almost requisite ‘reserva’ barrel toast, resin and spice. It is medium bodied, lively, fairly dense yet edgy with intense flavours. Should age very well.
Michael Godel – Pretty classic Rioja, dark fruit and dusty, barrel influence real and immediately notable, namely American in origin. Bits of char and plenty of essential savoury elements with all parts mingling and interacting famously.

Domaine De La Solitude Châteauneuf Du Pape 2022, Rhône, France
$54.95, Noble Estates Wines & Spirits Inc.
John Szabo – A dense and hugely satisfying vintage for the Lançon family’s classic La Solitude Châteauneuf, broad and thick, powerful and mouth coating, carrying 15.5% alcohol surprisingly. Tuck it in the cellar for at least another couple of years to soften the firm texture, or cellar late into the ‘30s without concern.
Michael Godel – An exotically charged and wildly aromatic Châteauneuf-du-Pâpe with so much fruit on the nose, repeated on the palate and acidity running favourably alongside. Manages its potential for massiveness with relative ease. Will age for a good long run.

Fattoria Dei Barbi Brunello Di Montalcino 2018, Tuscany, Italy
$69.95, Noble Estates Wines & Spirits Inc.
David Lawrason – This is a composed and complex Brunello heading into prime time but solid and balanced enough to age well for another decade. Textbook sangiovese aromas of raspberry and currant are joined by violets, fine fresh herbs (rosemary) and some foresty earthiness. Very well structured.

That’s all for this report, see round the next bottle.

John Szabo, MS

Use these quick links for access to all of our September 7th Top Picks in the New Release. Non-Premium members can select from all release dates 30 days prior.
Lawrason’s Take – September 7th
Michael’s Mix – September 7th
Sara’s Selections – September 7th
Szabo’s Smart Buys – September 7th

Don’t forget to follow us on Instagram for the latest WineAlign recommendations, tips and other interesting wine information.