I love the Closson Chase Chardonnays but have never liked their Pinot Noirs, finding past vintages overdone and out of balance. So I was surprised when I tasted this at the winery on the weekend that I actually liked it. Complex and interesting. I was interested enough to buy a bottle to see what I thought about when I opened it at home. I'm sure my rating will change after tasting it again. Not sure if it will up or down though. :)